Who is better? (music)

[Sektor]

Hey guys, this may seem really random but me and my friend always have a debate about which one is better. I would really appreciate if you cud vote and then comment why you voted on this. Which band is more legendary or better. The reason needs to be clear, eg. no , i vote for (whatever one you voted for) because they are the only ones i have heard. If you have heard neither type their a-s-s into youtube and hear songs from both bands. I really want to nail this guy is the augment because he is so c-o-ckey over the fact he thinks he is always right. I stand for NIN as i think they are superior, they have been going for longer, and have a much more wide range of music. There industrial grind sounds are amazing and Renzor is a legend. Thanks you all so very much for this, Wiping the floor with this guy and screaming OWNED at him wud be so amazing.

Get voting and remember that it is your view with a reason, Dnt just go with what i or anyone else think.

TY

[Mendez]

Never heard of either of them XD

I've never been much of a music person...

[Sektor]

Originally Posted by Mendez

Never heard of either of them XD

I've never been much of a music person...

Then listen and vote =]

[neuzd]

I don't know about Modest Mouse, but Reznor is the worst heroin addict musician of all times.

[Sektor]

Originally Posted by neuzd

I don't know about Modest Mouse, but Reznor is the worst heroin addict musician of all times.

True but can people plz get voting now

[iNma]

Modest Mouse ftw. Reznor hasn't made a decent album since Pretty Hate Machine (and damnstraight that includes both The Downward Spiral and Year Zero, which was more kitsch rock opera than proper album). And neuzd is right, too much of his output is influenced by narcotics...

The Moon and Antarctica is unlikely to be bettered by Modest Mouse, though The Lonesome Crowded West and Good News for People Who Love Bad News were good too. The new album is too sell-out pop for me, so that gets a thumbs down.

Of course, Neutral Milk Hotel's In The Airplane Over The Sea is better than all of the above.

[Sektor]

Originally Posted by iNma

Modest Mouse ftw. Reznor hasn't made a decent album since Pretty Hate Machine (and damnstraight that includes both The Downward Spiral and Year Zero, which was more kitsch rock opera than proper album). And neuzd is right, too much of his output is influenced by narcotics...

The Moon and Antarctica is unlikely to be bettered by Modest Mouse, though The Lonesome Crowded West and Good News for People Who Love Bad News were good too. The new album is too sell-out pop for me, so that gets a thumbs down.

Of course, Neutral Milk Hotel's In The Airplane Over The Sea is better than all of the above.

Hmmm... your opinion year zero is fantastic if you ask me even if a little different, so... anyone gonna defend and vote for nin like me?

:P

[Jaxathon]

Anything is better than Nine Inch Nails.

[Sektor]

Originally Posted by Jaxathon

Anything is better than Nine Inch Nails.

For ****s sake guys, NIN are awesome, come on!

[Makeda]

I hate NIN.. a friend of mine sent me a track from Year Zero and it sounded like a poor man's drunken industrial with the batteries dying on his synthesiser. I havent heard MM but I doubt they can be a s dire as NIN

[Tennant]

I prefer NIN to MM.

[Sektor]

YAY tennet!!

Someone is with me!

Get voting!

XD

can i vote that both suck?

[Sektor]

Originally Posted by facownage

can i vote that both suck?

If ya want

[crops55]

Not even a fair comparison. Both bands are so unlike each other that bringing both names into an argument is a little silly. But speaking of raw musical talent, I'd say Modest Mouse is the more complete package. If you can excuse their two most recent major label releases, Modest Mouse is an extremely rewarding band to listen to. They project one of the most unique sounds and host some of the best observational lyrics I've ever heard. Albums that are essential listens no matter what genre of music you like: The Moon and Antarctica, and The Lonesome Crowded West ( I challenge anybody to find me two better Indie rock albums bar the Pixies).

Inma I agree with you 100 percent in regards to the new album and my respect for you has just risen exponentially for your praise of the Moon and Antarctica.

[Tull]

Originally Posted by facownage

can i vote that both suck?

ditto