Odd how your guy's top players, were some of my worst
Edward: I wanted him to be sooo good, but he ended up being a total fail, in the Part 3 chapters he was a fail and even worse in part 4.
Nolan: Was good in the beginning, was even worse than Edward in Part 3 and 4. I couldn't even get them to attack anyone because they were so weak.
Aran: Utter fail, worse than the above.
Nephenee: Good, not great. There were times where she could really hold her own, but like the others, she really started sucking in the later chapters.
My best are:
Tirbarn
Naesala
Boyd
Ike
Rolf
On my next play through I'll be giving the littler characters a bigger shot, and the bigger characters less.